Want to compare two towns side by side?

Compare

Barton-under-Needwood vs Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

Which is better to live in? Distance: 13.1 miles apart.

Share this comparisonWhatsAppXFacebookEmail

The verdict

Overall, Barton Under Needwood offers lower property prices by roughly 46%. Melbourne (south Derbyshire) has the lower crime rate of the two. For families, Barton Under Needwood edges ahead on school quality.

Avg House Price

Barton-under-Needwood

£190,899

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

£352,966

Crime Rate

Barton-under-Needwood

63.9

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

52.7

Top-Two School Inspection Bands

Barton-under-Needwood

100.0%

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

100.0%

Avg Download Speed

Barton-under-Needwood

228.9

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

463

EPC Rating

Barton-under-Needwood

71.5

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

71.6

Median Income

Barton-under-Needwood

£33,210

Melbourne (South Derbyshire)

£32,236

Buyers will find Barton Under Needwood more wallet-friendly, where the average price is £190,899 versus £352,966 in Melbourne (south Derbyshire). The most affordable entry point in Barton Under Needwood is a flat at £108,707, while in Melbourne (south Derbyshire) it is a flat at £198,750.

Average Price by Property Type (2025)

Biggest gap: semi-detached homes are 46% pricier in Melbourne (south Derbyshire) (£341,307 vs £184,670).

Price Trend (11 Years)

Over the last 9 years, Melbourne (south Derbyshire) prices grew faster — 30% vs 24%.

With 52.7 offences per 1,000 people, Melbourne (south Derbyshire) is the safer of the two – 21% lower than Barton Under Needwood's 63.9 per 1,000. The most common crime category in Barton Under Needwood is violent-crime, while in Melbourne (south Derbyshire) it is violent-crime.

Crime Rate by Category (per 1,000 residents)

Both towns share the same top crime category: violent crime.

School quality favours Barton Under Needwood: 100% of its schools are in the top two inspection bands, compared with 100% in Melbourne (south Derbyshire).

Barton-under-Needwood School Inspection Breakdown

100% of 3 schools (2 primary, 1 secondary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

Melbourne (South Derbyshire) School Inspection Breakdown

100% of 2 schools (2 primary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

MetricBarton-under-NeedwoodMelbourne (South Derbyshire)
Total Schools32
Primary22
Secondary10
% Top two bands100%100%

Broadband & Connectivity

Internet users in Melbourne (south Derbyshire) enjoy 463.0 Mbps on average, while Barton Under Needwood lags behind at 228.9 Mbps. Superfast coverage (30 Mbps+) reaches 90.7% of premises in Barton Under Needwood and 97% in Melbourne (south Derbyshire). Gigabit availability stands at 36% in Barton Under Needwood and 91.5% in Melbourne (south Derbyshire).

Melbourne (south Derbyshire) is the faster of the two by 102% on average download speed (463 vs 229 Mbps).

Energy Efficiency & Running Costs

The average EPC rating in Melbourne (south Derbyshire) is band C (score 71.6), ahead of Barton Under Needwood's band C (score 71.5). Estimated annual energy costs average £1,179 in Barton Under Needwood and £1,142 in Melbourne (south Derbyshire). 66.5% of homes in Barton Under Needwood have an EPC rating of C or above, compared to 64.4% in Melbourne (south Derbyshire).

Barton Under Needwood has more energy-efficient housing — 66.5% reach band C or above, vs 64.4% in the other.

Demographics & Economy

Barton Under Needwood has a population of 4,713 while Melbourne (south Derbyshire) has 4,860. Median household income is £33,210.3 in Barton Under Needwood and £32,236.3 in Melbourne (south Derbyshire). The median age is 44.1 in Barton Under Needwood and 42.5 in Melbourne (south Derbyshire). Employment rates stand at 59.3% in Barton Under Needwood and 59.3% in Melbourne (south Derbyshire).

IndicatorBarton-under-NeedwoodMelbourne (South Derbyshire)
Population4,7134,860
Median Age44.142.5
Median Household Income£33,210.3£32,236.3
Employment Rate59.3%59.3%
Owner Occupied71.5%68.4%
Degree-Level Qualified31.4%30.5%

Location

Loading map...

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

How far apart are Barton Under Needwood and Melbourne (south Derbyshire)?
Barton Under Needwood and Melbourne (south Derbyshire) are approximately 13.1 miles apart as the crow flies.
Which is cheaper to buy a house in, Barton Under Needwood or Melbourne (south Derbyshire)?
Barton Under Needwood is cheaper, with an average house price of £190,899.
Is Barton Under Needwood or Melbourne (south Derbyshire) safer?
Melbourne (south Derbyshire) has the lower crime rate at 52.7 per 1,000 residents.
Which has better schools, Barton Under Needwood or Melbourne (south Derbyshire)?
Barton Under Needwood has the higher share of schools in the top two inspection bands at 100%.
Which has faster broadband, Barton Under Needwood or Melbourne (south Derbyshire)?
Melbourne (south Derbyshire) has faster average broadband at 463.0 Mbps.

Keep exploring

Related comparisons