Want to compare two towns side by side?

Compare

Birstall vs Broughton Astley

Which is better to live in? Distance: 11.3 miles apart.

Share this comparisonWhatsAppXFacebookEmail

The verdict

Property in Birstall is about 22% cheaper on average. Broughton Astley has the lower crime rate of the two. For families, Birstall edges ahead on school quality.

Avg House Price

Birstall

£260,306

Broughton Astley

£334,722

Crime Rate

Birstall

68.0

Broughton Astley

31.1

Top-Two School Inspection Bands

Birstall

100.0%

Broughton Astley

66.7%

Avg Download Speed

Birstall

486.2

Broughton Astley

292.2

EPC Rating

Birstall

70.4

Broughton Astley

71

Median Income

Birstall

£30,112

Broughton Astley

£31,173

Buyers will find Birstall more wallet-friendly, where the average price is £260,306 versus £334,722 in Broughton Astley. The most affordable entry point in Birstall is a flat at £166,694, while in Broughton Astley it is a terraced at £211,873.

Average Price by Property Type (2025)

Biggest gap: detached homes are 14% pricier in Broughton Astley (£411,612 vs £353,215).

Price Trend (11 Years)

Over the last 9 years, Broughton Astley prices grew faster — 44% vs 39%.

Crime is lower in Broughton Astley (31.1 per 1,000) compared to Birstall (68 per 1,000), a 119% difference. The most common crime category in Birstall is violent-crime, while in Broughton Astley it is criminal-damage-arson.

Crime Rate by Category (per 1,000 residents)

Birstall's most common crime is violent crime; in Broughton Astley it's criminal damage & arson.

School quality favours Birstall: 100% of its schools are in the top two inspection bands, compared with 66.7% in Broughton Astley.

Birstall School Inspection Breakdown

100% of 4 schools (3 primary, 1 secondary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

Broughton Astley School Inspection Breakdown

66.7% of 4 schools (3 primary, 1 secondary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

MetricBirstallBroughton Astley
Total Schools44
Primary33
Secondary11
% Top two bands100%66.7%

Broadband & Connectivity

Internet users in Birstall enjoy 486.2 Mbps on average, while Broughton Astley lags behind at 292.2 Mbps. Superfast coverage (30 Mbps+) reaches 99.1% of premises in Birstall and 95.6% in Broughton Astley. Gigabit availability stands at 96.8% in Birstall and 48.5% in Broughton Astley.

Birstall is the faster of the two by 66% on average download speed (486 vs 292 Mbps).

Energy Efficiency & Running Costs

The average EPC rating in Broughton Astley is band C (score 71), ahead of Birstall's band C (score 70.4). Estimated annual energy costs average £1,102 in Birstall and £1,245 in Broughton Astley. 62.4% of homes in Birstall have an EPC rating of C or above, compared to 61.5% in Broughton Astley.

Birstall has more energy-efficient housing — 62.4% reach band C or above, vs 61.5% in the other.

Demographics & Economy

Birstall has a population of 13,960 while Broughton Astley has 9,649. Median household income is £31,172.7 in Broughton Astley and £30,111.7 in Birstall. The median age is 41.2 in Birstall and 45.2 in Broughton Astley. Employment rates stand at 56.7% in Birstall and 60.5% in Broughton Astley.

IndicatorBirstallBroughton Astley
Population13,9609,649
Median Age41.245.2
Median Household Income£30,111.7£31,172.7
Employment Rate56.7%60.5%
Owner Occupied64.8%76%
Degree-Level Qualified30%32.6%

Location

Loading map...

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

How far apart are Birstall and Broughton Astley?
Birstall and Broughton Astley are approximately 11.3 miles apart as the crow flies.
Which is cheaper to buy a house in, Birstall or Broughton Astley?
Birstall is cheaper, with an average house price of £260,306.
Is Birstall or Broughton Astley safer?
Broughton Astley has the lower crime rate at 31.1 per 1,000 residents.
Which has better schools, Birstall or Broughton Astley?
Birstall has the higher share of schools in the top two inspection bands at 100%.
Which has faster broadband, Birstall or Broughton Astley?
Birstall has faster average broadband at 486.2 Mbps.

Keep exploring

Related comparisons