Want to compare two towns side by side?

Compare

Brotton vs Great Ayton

Which is better to live in? Distance: 9.6 miles apart.

Share this comparisonWhatsAppXFacebookEmail

The verdict

Brotton is the more affordable option, with average house prices around 52% lower. Great Ayton has the lower crime rate of the two. For families, Brotton edges ahead on school quality.

Avg House Price

Brotton

£136,266

Great Ayton

£283,263

Crime Rate

Brotton

107.4

Great Ayton

47.6

Top-Two School Inspection Bands

Brotton

100.0%

Great Ayton

100.0%

Avg Download Speed

Brotton

340

Great Ayton

296.8

EPC Rating

Brotton

70.7

Great Ayton

70.3

Median Income

Brotton

£26,481

Great Ayton

£29,468

At £136,266, Brotton undercuts Great Ayton (£283,263) by around 52% on average house prices. The most affordable entry point in Brotton is a terraced at £60,712, while in Great Ayton it is a flat at £194,889.

Average Price by Property Type (2025)

Biggest gap: terraced homes are 71% pricier in Great Ayton (£208,455 vs £60,712).

Price Trend (11 Years)

Over the last 9 years, Great Ayton prices grew faster — 47% vs 19%.

Great Ayton has a crime rate of 47.6 per 1,000 residents, which is 126% lower than Brotton at 107.4 per 1,000. The most common crime category in Brotton is violent-crime, while in Great Ayton it is violent-crime.

Crime Rate by Category (per 1,000 residents)

Both towns share the same top crime category: violent crime.

Of the 3 schools in Brotton, 100% are in the top two inspection bands. In Great Ayton, which has 2 schools, the figure is 100%.

Brotton School Inspection Breakdown

100% of 3 schools (2 primary, 1 secondary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

Great Ayton School Inspection Breakdown

100% of 2 schools (2 primary) sit in the top two inspection bands.

MetricBrottonGreat Ayton
Total Schools32
Primary22
Secondary10
% Top two bands100%100%

Broadband & Connectivity

Broadband in Brotton averages 340.0 Mbps – ahead of Great Ayton's 296.8 Mbps. Superfast coverage (30 Mbps+) reaches 88.6% of premises in Brotton and 78.4% in Great Ayton. Gigabit availability stands at 63.6% in Brotton and 53.2% in Great Ayton.

Brotton is the faster of the two by 15% on average download speed (340 vs 297 Mbps).

Energy Efficiency & Running Costs

Brotton leads on energy efficiency with an average EPC score of 70.7 (C), while Great Ayton averages 70.3 (C). Estimated annual energy costs average £1,176 in Brotton and £1,400 in Great Ayton. 61.5% of homes in Brotton have an EPC rating of C or above, compared to 59.8% in Great Ayton.

Brotton has more energy-efficient housing — 61.5% reach band C or above, vs 59.8% in the other.

Demographics & Economy

Median household income is £29,468.2 in Great Ayton and £26,481 in Brotton. The median age is 46 in Brotton and 47.8 in Great Ayton. Owner-occupancy is 64.7% in Brotton versus 67.9% in Great Ayton. Employment rates stand at 49.5% in Brotton and 56% in Great Ayton.

IndicatorBrottonGreat Ayton
Population5,3994,348
Median Age4647.8
Median Household Income£26,481£29,468.2
Employment Rate49.5%56%
Owner Occupied64.7%67.9%
Degree-Level Qualified24.9%33%

Location

Loading map...

Common questions

Frequently asked questions

How far apart are Brotton and Great Ayton?
Brotton and Great Ayton are approximately 9.6 miles apart as the crow flies.
Which is cheaper to buy a house in, Brotton or Great Ayton?
Brotton is cheaper, with an average house price of £136,266.
Is Brotton or Great Ayton safer?
Great Ayton has the lower crime rate at 47.6 per 1,000 residents.
Which has better schools, Brotton or Great Ayton?
Brotton has the higher share of schools in the top two inspection bands at 100%.
Which has faster broadband, Brotton or Great Ayton?
Brotton has faster average broadband at 340.0 Mbps.

Keep exploring

Related comparisons